Good Sport NYC went live on May 8th, so we just hit the six-month mark last week. I’m a sucker for a milestone, especially as an excuse to take stock, so I’ve written out my reflections on Good Sport’s first few months, and I’m sharing ‘em for the love of #BuildingInPublic. We also recorded a podcast episode you can listen to instead, though I go into more detail below.
Here’s where we’ve been, where we’re going, and what I’m wrestling with, starting with the stats.
Where we’ve been: By the numbers
As of writing on November 19th, Good Sport has 437 total Substack subscribers, 21 of whom are on a paid plan. That’s about 5% of our total audience, which I’ve read is healthy. Nice! Most of those paid subs are my friends or friends of friends, but a handful of folks I have no connection to have upgraded to paid. And when they do…I’m soaring.
Do I pay attention to these numbers? Yes! I get an email every time someone subscribes. I yearn for the day we hit 1,000. Have I cared about them all that much? Not really, because a few weeks into this thing, the true weight of the work hit, and it became clear the first stretch of this project would be spent figuring out how to make the newsletter and podcast every week, on top of my full-time job.
So promoting Good Sport—all the marketing work of a project like this—hasn’t been a priority. Most of our current audience comes from word of mouth (aka my personal social followers and friends), the Substack network, and referrals from other publications (s/o to fellow indie publications Rough Notes and GUNK).
Where we’ve been: Intangibles & other highlights
I’d be remiss not to mention some of the really cool shit that’s happened in the Good Sportian universe so far. Of course as the ~founder~ (maybe by the one-year mark I’ll be able to claim that word without indicating I’m not taking myself too seriously), many moments—both big and small—are gems to me, filled with encouraging doses of confidence that I should keep it pumping. Too many to count.
We’ve done four events so far, and each one has left me feeling energized and pleasantly surprised by the turnout. Our first event was a big knockout game back in June, and 60ish people came through. Last week we did a sports-themed reading event with Reading 101, and it was packed to the damn gills.
Another early highlight: The podcast guests we’ve had on the show. Interviewing folks working in women’s sports, talking to people about NYC W sports culture, has been incredibly fun and rewarding. We haven’t cracked the right format for the podcast yet (more on that below), but the first 20ish episodes have led to extremely meaningful connections and Good Sport supporters.
Where we’re going
All that said, it’s time I get more strategic about our growth. While our early audience is healthily engaged—we’ve got a ~50% average open rate on our newsletters—the more folks we have in our orbit, the easier it’ll be to learn what’s working, and where we should focus. The goal here is to build a business that provides value (media & experiences) to customers (women’s sports fans). So we'd better go and find them.
That said, it is abundantly clear that I can’t make the newsletter and podcast and do that vital promotional work, like making videos and social content, alone. I fear it is a skill issue, though put some respect on my Canva Pro account. And I just don’t have the time to do it all.
So here’s how we’re addressing all of the above:
Team expansion. Earlier this month, I brought a designer and video editor onto the GS team to help with a lot of the work I just mentioned. I am so stoked to have them.
Focus and do less. We’re currently doing a lot of different things—newsletter, podcast, events, etc.—around what is somehow both a niche and a broad subject: NYC women’s sports. We need to focus our scope in each channel and get really clear about why we’re doing it. With limited resources, I’d rather do a few things really well than many things kinda medium.
Slow down. In all the hustle of making the thing, important systems and measurement rituals haven’t been built yet. This is natural when you’re early and don’t have a lot of time, but I think it’ll help us with point no. 2 above. And help us answer some of the big questions below.
Big questions
Here are some things I continue to think about and wrestle with as I work on Good Sport:
Coverage vs culture. Do we focus on actual women’s sports coverage, or the culture of women’s sports? We’ve done both in these first six months, and I think in many ways you can’t have one without the other, but it behooves a brand to plant a flag. The Good Sport universe has room for both, but I honestly feel a lot more qualified to talk about the latter, though I want to consume media on the former.
Build the big brand vs the NYC brand. The goal is that one day, Good Sport NYC will be a part of a bigger network that uplifts women’s sports in cities across the country. I have a lot of conviction that there is a market for more locally-focused women’s sports media, but I’m not sure if I should start by proving the concept out here with Good Sport NYC, or try to build a flagship Good Sport brand that can then go on to nurture those hubs.
Finances. I self-fund Good Sport right now, which I’m able to do because I’ve made good money working in marketing at tech companies for the last six years and can use some savings + part of my salary to put towards this work. With the ambitions of this project, there will come a time when I can’t do that anymore. Then I’ll need to make some decisions about raising some money or other ways to finance Good Sport.
Time. I mentioned above that I have a full-time job, and I must also mention that I actually love that job, in a way I didn’t know was possible. If Good Sport were to become what I hope, it would need to be my only job. I don’t think we’re anywhere close to that being an actual thing—maybe check back in 2028—but it’s something I think about.
In conclusion
So that’s where we’re at. Phew! I’m going to take the rest of the year to work with the team on a lot of this stuff. We’re taking a podcast hiatus until 2027, and then we’ll be back with a refocused show. The weekly Monday newsletter will continue to focus on NYC women’s sports news and culture. The podcast is gonna head in a different direction. More soon.
I’m excited for what’s next, and so thankful for everyone who’s supported Good Sport so far. Many friends have offered time and skills for free or homie prices. I am endlessly grateful.
I’m writing this at 11:30 am in Amsterdam while on vacation with my girlfriend, finishing it up before we bike around all day. She’s an OBGYN resident doctor, and the undisputed chief grinder in our relationship. But her being down for this, for me spending a lot of time on a project with an unknown trajectory, is invaluable. So if you’re reading this and want to start your own thing, my biggest recommendation is to bring your loved ones in early, ask them for help, and make it fun for you and for them. We can talk strategy all day, but community will keep the wheels running.
Even if you’re “doing it solo,” you’re not. <3 No one ever is.









